Woman lands job after CEO asks why she shouldn't be hired: 'I wasn't ready for that question'

hindustantimes.com
It's surprising how interviewers are finding creative ways to test candidates, sometimes asking questions that seem almost impossible to answer on the spot.

Recently, a woman experienced this firsthand and turned it into an opportunity that landed her a job.

According to the post, during her interview, the CEO asked her to give one good reason why she shouldn't be hired.

Katyayani Shukla shared the incident on X (formerly Twitter) with the caption, "During my last job interview, the CEO asked me to give her one good reason not to hire me."

"I told her I wasn't ready for that question and needed some time to think," she adds.

Most people might have expected the CEO to forget, but a few hours later, she received a follow-up message requesting her response. After reflecting carefully, Shukla wrote her answer, and the result was a job offer.

She began by apologising if her answer was long, explaining that it came from careful thought.

"A good reason not to hire me is that I have my life together. What that means for me is that I keep my personal and professional life organised," the email reads.

Shukla further explained that she has her time to work, usually around 9 to 5 on weekdays, and she sets boundaries to keep work inside those hours.

"I genuinely believe that when everything is urgent, nothing is urgent," she adds.

She added that setting boundaries is important for people to respect her as a professional. While some may appreciate that, others might see it as a red flag.

"Being organised and mindful of my time, and other people's time, is very important to me," the email further read.
5   
  • f h

    3w

    That’s an excellent response, it emphasizes strong work ethics, boundaries and expectations up front. If that answer did not result in a job offer... then perhaps it may not be a supportive work culture.  more

  • A strong answer to this question isn’t about disqualifying yourself, it’s about showing self-awareness, honesty, and growth without raising red flags.... The key is to frame a manageable limitation and show how you actively address it. more

  • good...i don't quite know how i would have answered that question

  • That was an excellent answer. In the time that we live in work life balance is so important. This also helps with burn out as well as our mental... health. more